A dramatic twist almost rewrote Survivor history. Jeremiah Ing, recently voted out of “Survivor 49,” shared with The Post an exclusive insight into what he believed could have been an unprecedented 1-1-1 tie vote during the tribal council featured in Wednesday’s episode, involving himself, Sophi Baledri, and Alex Moore.
The 39-year-old global events manager recounted, “I caught on that Sophi had turned against me. We had a conversation where she asked about Alex’s stance, and right there, I realized she’d flipped.” He explained his thought process: “I wasn’t sure where Alex stood, but I assumed Alex was targeting Sophi while I was voting for Alex. That’s why I expected the vote to split evenly three ways.”
Jeremiah seriously debated using his Shot in the Dark advantage — a risky move that offers a chance to save oneself by drawing a chance-based token — but ultimately hesitated. “The fear was if I played it and lost, I’d automatically be out. So I walked into tribal knowing there was about a fifty-fifty chance I'd be sent home.” He acknowledged that his mindset might have been fogged by exhaustion and stress, saying, “Maybe it was just my delirious state from everything going on around me, but that’s honestly what I expected.”
But here’s where it gets controversial: does this reveal a bigger gameplay strategy mistake? Should he have risked the Shot in the Dark? Would that have changed the outcome?
Jeremiah also spoke candidly about the shocking medical evacuation of fellow tribe member Jake Latimer after a venomous snake bite — an event no player wants to face. “Regardless of who you are, even if someone is your biggest rival or someone you can't stand, you never, ever wish something so serious on anyone,” he said. “We all went through a brutal selection process just to get here. We want to play, yes, but life-threatening situations are a whole different level. It’s frightening and heartbreaking.”
The tribe was blindsided when host Jeff Probst announced Jake’s departure at the immunity challenge. Jeremiah described the moment vividly: “I arrived and immediately noticed Jake was missing — I even had his backpack. Then Jeff broke the news that Jake wasn’t coming back. It hit us all like a bolt out of the blue.”
In an attempt to stay optimistic, Jeremiah admitted, “Part of me hoped Jake might return, but then Alex mentioned the snake bite was on the foot and that the snake was highly venomous. That was a hard reality check.”
This incident reminds us just how unpredictable and physically perilous the game can be — far beyond mere strategy and alliances.
"Survivor" continues to air on Wednesdays at 8 pm ET on CBS.
What do you think about Jeremiah’s choice not to risk Shot in the Dark? Was it a calculated move or a missed opportunity? Share your thoughts below — this one sparks strong opinions for sure.
