Get ready to dive back into the chilling world of a serial killer’s twisted mind—because The Creep Tapes is not only returning for Season 2 but has already been greenlit for a third season before the second even premieres! But here’s where it gets controversial: Is this found-footage horror series pushing the boundaries too far, or is it the perfect evolution of the genre? Let’s break it down.
Back in 2014, the dynamic duo of writer/director Patrick Brice and co-writer/star Mark Duplass teamed up with Blumhouse Productions to deliver Creep, a found-footage horror film that left audiences both terrified and craving more. Its success led to Creep 2 in 2017, and while a third film was initially planned to wrap up the trilogy, the creators pivoted to a TV series instead. Enter The Creep Tapes, a six-episode series that premiered on Shudder and AMC+ last November, shattering records as the most-watched Shudder show ever on AMC+ and driving unprecedented subscriber growth. Now, with Season 2 set to drop on November 14th, Shudder has already ordered Season 3 for 2026, proving this franchise is far from done haunting us.
The Creep Tapes delves into the psyche of a reclusive serial killer who lures videographers into his lair with the promise of a paid gig documenting his life. And this is the part most people miss: As the cameras roll, his bizarre behavior and sinister intentions unfold, leaving his victims—and viewers—questioning whether they’ve made a fatal mistake. Season 2 promises more of the same heart-pounding tension, with Duplass reprising his role alongside an impressive lineup of guest stars, including David Dastmalchian (Late Night with the Devil), Robert Longstreet (The Haunting of Hill House), and Katie Aselton (Black Rock).
Produced by Duplass Brothers Productions and Shudder, the series is a labor of love for Brice and Duplass, who serve as executive producers, writers, and directors. But here’s the kicker: While they still plan to conclude the franchise with Creep 3, they’re clearly having a blast with The Creep Tapes. Bold question: Is this series a genius expansion of the Creep universe, or is it stretching the concept too thin? Let us know in the comments!
For horror fans, The Creep Tapes is a must-watch—a masterclass in psychological horror that keeps you guessing until the very end. Are you as excited as we are for Season 3? Or do you think the series should have ended with the films? Sound off below and join the debate!
